Discover the Best Rye Whiskey | Affordable Options & Top Shelf Options
top of page
    • Mar 3

Discover the Best Rye Whiskey | Affordable Options & Top Shelf Options

What is Rye Whiskey


If you're a whiskey aficionado or just a casual drinker who is curious about the different types of whiskey, then rye whiskey might be one that you've heard of. Rye whiskey is similar to bourbon, but it's made with at least 51% rye grain instead of corn. This gives it a spicy, sometimes fruity flavor that sets it apart from other types of whiskey. It's been around since the colonial days when American farmers were growing rye crops abundantly. In fact, George Washington himself even operated a rye whiskey distillery. Rye whiskey has seen a resurgence in popularity in recent years as more people try to switch up their whiskey preferences and explore new flavors.


The Best Rye Whiskey | Affordable Options Under $100


Raise your glasses, whiskey lovers! I have a list of amazing rye whiskeys that won't break the bank. Rye whiskey is a classic American spirit with a long history, and these affordable options will make you feel like you're taking a sip of history without draining your wallet. From spicy to smooth, each of these whiskeys has its unique flavor to tantalize your taste buds. Sipping on a dram of rye whiskey is a great way to relax after a long day, and with these options, it won't cost you an arm and a leg. So, why not treat yourself to a fantastic rye whiskey without breaking the bank? It's time to explore my favorite/affordable options and add some new classics to your home bar.


Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, and Affiliate Partner of other products discussed on my website I earn from qualifying purchases. This does not cost you anything extra and helps me keep this website running. All of my reviews and recommendations are my own and not influenced by any sponsorships or collaborations.


Pikesville Straight Rye Whiskey

Crafted by Heaven Hills Co-Master Distiller Denny Potter, Pikesville Straight Rye Whiskey is an exceptional creation. It combines rye, corn, and barley to deliver the distinctive spiciness reminiscent of traditional Maryland rye whiskies. What sets it apart is the careful selection of six-year-old barrels from high-storage, plus setting the proof just right to amplify the delightful barrel character without overpowering the spicy grain notes.


This results in Pikesville Straight Rye Whiskey, boasting a captivating pale copper color and an enticing aroma of dark cocoa and burnt oak. When you take a sip, you'll be immersed in layers of honey, clover, and white chocolate, leading to a memorable finish highlighted by hints of vanilla bean, butterscotch candy, maple syrup, and caramel. It's no wonder that Pikesville Rye Whisky earned a well-deserved Double Gold at the 2015 San Francisco World Spirits Competition and an impressive 95 points at the 2015 Ultimate Spirits Challenge. This one is probably the best rye whiskey for the money and a great place to start if you are new to the world of rye whiskey.


Russell's Reserve Rye Whiskey

Russell's Reserve 6-Year-Old Small Batch Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey is made using a generations-old recipe. The rye is distilled at a lower proof than other Kentucky distilleries, resulting in less water dilution before maturation. Aged for a minimum of six years in heavily charred American oak casks, the unique maturation process contributes bold flavors of honey, wood tannins, and cinnamon, complementing the spicy rye notes.


The individual casks are carefully hand-selected by Russell and his son, Eddie, who have over 90 years of combined whiskey-making experience. Finally, the whiskey is bottled by hand after reaching the desired proof. This exceptional rye whiskey has been recognized with a Double Gold Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, earning the title of "Best Rye Whiskey," and receiving an outstanding score of 96-100 points from Wine Enthusiast.


If you need some great whiskey glasses, I highly recommend this Glencairn Set and the Libbey Signature Kentucky Bourbon Trail set below. These are my go-to glasses for whiskey tasting.


Glencairn Glasses

Libbey Glasses with wooden paddle

High West Rendezvous Rye Whiskey

Discover the robust character of High West's High Rye Drifter, a select spirit born in the heart of the Rocky Mountains. Nestled in Park City, Utah, High West emerged as a beacon of distilling craftsmanship in 2007 with founder David Perkins at the helm—a nod to its pioneering spirit as Utah's first legally licensed distillery post-Prohibition. The passionate artisans at High West honor traditional methods, distilling in small, attentive batches. While renowned for their expertise in sourcing and blending exceptional spirits, a portion of their collection is lovingly distilled in-house—a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor.


The Rendezvous expression represents a masterful dance between two distinct straight Rye Whiskies, united by their predominant rye heritage yet each bringing its own story. A bold 6-year-old whiskey boasts an impressive 95% rye mash bill, delivering a spirited zest. It's gracefully paired with a mellow 16-year-old whiskey, its 80% rye composition evoking the deep wisdom of age. Together, their flavors intertwine, creating a symphony where the younger rye's vibrant energy complements the aged rye's profound complexity—the pure essence of rye crystallized in a glass. Immerse yourself in a Rye that speaks volumes, where each sip reveals the lore of the mountains and the unwavering dedication of High West Distillery. The High Rye Drifter awaits your discovery.

Use my exclusive Caskers.com discount code: WHISKEYFOOL10 to receive $10 off qualifying* orders. Copy and paste to use at checkout.

*$100 or more

Knob Creek Rye Whiskey

Knob Creek, renowned for their impressive array of whiskeys and bourbons, has become a beloved staple among spirit connoisseurs. The renaissance of Rye Whiskey has been nothing short of remarkable, and Knob Creek's contribution with its small batch rye is a testament to this revival. A tapestry of bold rye weaves harmoniously with subtle oak and vanillin whispers, crafting a symphony for the senses that has rightfully earned its place at the pinnacle of whiskey admiration.


While the age remains a mysterious element – an exercise in patience as indicated on its label – and the grains' origins kept under wraps, acknowledged only as the 'finest quality rye', there's little wonder as to why this whiskey clinched the title of "Best Rye Worldwide Whiskey" at the 2016 International Wine and Spirits Competition. Whether you're a whiskey aficionado or new to the realm of ryes, Knob Creek Rye Whiskey promises an experience rich with heritage and flavor.


Angel's Envy Rum Cask Finished Rye Whiskey

Discover the exceptional Angels Envy Rye, a whiskey aficionado’s delight, with its exclusive bi-annual release that marks the seasons of harvest and renewal. Each small batch is meticulously finished in select Plantation XO Rum Casks, which carry the legacy of aged French cognac within their wooden staves. The result? A magnificent confluence where the untamed spice of rye gracefully dances with the suave sweetness of premium rum, delivering a sip that's layered with intrigue and sophistication.


It's this signature complexity that sets it apart as one of my top rye whiskey recommendations—often within reach for those who appreciate a true gem in the world of spirits. Warm, inviting, and rich in detail, this rye was crafted to please the discerning whiskey drinker. Indulge in a glass of Angels Envy Rye and savor the extraordinary journey of flavors that awaits. I love the way the rum enhances the rye in this bottle. See my in-depth review of Angel's Envy Rye here. Just buy this one! You won't be disappointed.




Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye Whiskey

 Experience the epitome of craftsmanship with Wild Turkey's Rare Breed – a collection that has captured the hearts of whiskey connoisseurs and the acclaim of critics globally. Each bottle is a bacchanal of awards, boasting Double Gold Medals from the San Francisco World Spirits Competition and Gold Medals from the International Wine & Spirits Competition, among a long list of other accolades.


Rare Breed's rye whiskey, bottled at a robust 112.2 proof, is a masterful addition to the distillery's eminent barrel-proof range. Unfiltered and uncut, this whiskey delivers an intricate flavor profile that I absolutely love. This is a great product and one of the best rye whiskey deals out there. See my in-depth review of Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye here.



Willett Family Estate 4-year Rye Whiskey

Discover the bold taste and rich history of Willett Family Estate's 4-Year-Old Small Batch Rye. This Rye Whiskey delivers a punch of plums on the palate, reflecting the Willett family's whiskey-making legacy dating back to the 1700s. Handcrafted at the new Willett Distilling Company since 2012, each batch boasts unique flavors at a cask-strength proof. At just 4 years old this whiskey delivers a rich and complex experience. Enjoy the tradition and craftsmanship in every sip.


Use my exclusive Caskers.com discount code: WHISKEYFOOL10 to receive $10 off qualifying* orders. Copy and paste to use at checkout.

*$100 or more

The Best Rye Whiskey | Top Shelf/Premium Options (Above $100)


For the true connoisseur on the hunt for excellence, this curated list of top-shelf rye whiskies represents the pinnacle of craftsmanship and flavor. These bottles may require a bit more effort and investment to locate, but the reward is a tasting experience that transcends the ordinary. Each dram is a testament to the distiller's art—a balance of robust, spicy notes perfected by time and tradition. Savoring these will not only delight your palate but also affirm that the best things in life are worth pursuing. Whether you’re expanding your collection or seeking that exceptional gift, these rye whiskies promise to be the crowning jewels of any whiskey cabinet. You are unlikely to find any of these at your local liquor store unless you win a liquor lottery. Typically, if you want one of these you will have to pay a secondary market price for them.


Van Winkle Family Reserve 13 Year Rye Whiskey

Honoring the legacy of a distilling pioneer, Van Winkle Bourbons delivers a revered rye whiskey that is sure to delight enthusiasts and aficionados alike. With each sip, you'll be part of a distinguished American whiskey tradition. Crafted with passion in the rolling hills of Kentucky, this esteemed rye has matured for over 13 years, securing its place as one of the oldest ryes available today. Although it’s rare to find on store shelves, this storied bottle offers a sumptuous discovery for those fortunate enough to enjoy its deep and rich flavors.



Aged & Charred Smoker Kit


Sazerac 18-Year Straight Rye Whiskey

Discover the origins of America's inaugural cocktail—the legendary Sazerac. Born within the historic walls of New Orleans' Sazerac Coffee House, this cocktail has undeniably carved its niche in mixology lore. Celebrating two decadent decades, Buffalo Trace Distillery honored its Antique Collection's 20th anniversary with a landmark release. The commemorative Sazerac Rye 18-Year-Old, set to an exact 90 proof, is a product of the spring of 2002 distillation. Standing out with its aged rye rarity, this double-digit elixir proves exceedingly elusive, a gem amongst its counterparts. "There's no Rye Whiskey quite as aged—or exquisitely balanced—as this one," declares Whisky Advocate, affirming its unparalleled presence in a thriving whiskey domain.


Use my exclusive Caskers.com discount code: WHISKEYFOOL10 to receive $10 off qualifying* orders. Copy and paste to use at checkout.

*$100 or more

Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey

The Antique Collection from Buffalo Trace stands as a paragon within the world of ultra-premium whiskey, boasting a storied tapestry of expressions that have consistently triumphed at prestigious awards. The Thomas Handy Sazerac, a singular whiskey in this collection, pays homage to its namesake, an illustrious New Orleans bartender renowned for pioneering the usage of rye whiskey in the legendary Sazerac cocktail.


Each bottle of the Thomas Handy Sazerac is a testament to Buffalo Traces' commitment to excellence, filled straight from the barrel to preserve every hint of its character. This whiskey remains audaciously bold and unapologetically rich, presented to connoisseurs exactly as nature intended—uncut and unfiltered.

The 2021 release, a cut above the rest, hails back to its distillation year of 2015. Crafted from a select blend of Minnesota rye, Kentucky corn, and North Dakota malted barley, this spirit reflects a symphony of regional terroir. After maturing for over 6 years and 4 months in superior #4 char white oak barrels, the whiskey reached its zenith, bottled at an impressive 129.5 proof.


Invoking a refined, enthusiastic, and authoritative spirit, the Thomas Handy Sazerac continues to leave an indelible mark on the world of fine spirits—a true jewel among whiskeys, this cask strength rye is awaiting the appreciation of those who understand its profound lineage and exceptional quality.



Larceny Very Special Small Batch Bourbon

Leveraging his distilling know-how and political clout, Taylor, along with Treasury Secretary John G. Carlisle, played a critical role in the creation and adoption of the Bottled-In-Bond Act of 1897. This pivotal legislation imposed strict regulations on spirits bearing the "Bonded" or "Bottled-in-Bond" designation, ensuring they came from a single distiller, at one distillery, within one distillation season. Additionally, it stipulated that such spirits must mature in a federal bond warehouse for at least four years under the watchful eye of the U.S. government and be bottled at exactly 100 proof.


The Colonel E.H. Taylor, Jr. Straight Rye Whiskey bottled in bond pays homage to its namesake's legacy, crafted exclusively from rye and malted barley—completely omitting corn. This yields a drink highlighted by an array of dark spices, elegantly offset by subtle caramel tones. Each bottle of this 100-proof, bonded spirit is sealed with the richness of a dry, oak-laden finish, accented with hints of cinnamon and vanilla. The presentation is equally nostalgic, featuring vintage labeling and an antique-style canister that harkens back to the packaging Taylor pioneered over a century ago.



Michter's 10-Year Straight Rye Whiskey | Single Barrel

The Michter's 10-Year-Old Single Barrel Straight Rye Whiskey, meticulously matured in air-dried barrels, exemplifies a single-barrel whiskey of bold character bursting with rich flavors. Crafted with a mash bill comprising over half rye, this whiskey's smoldering, potent profile has garnered an international cult following. Each small batch of Michter's 10-Year-Old Single Barrel Straight Rye is a unique experience, promising an unrivaled whiskey experience.



Wild Turkey Master's Keep Cornerstone Rye

Indulge in the distinguished Wild Turkey Master's Keep collection which showcases their most aged rye whiskey to date. The latest, fourth installment is not merely an exquisitely aged spirit; it reigns as Wild Turkey's most senior rye release. Masterfully selected by Eddie Russel, this blend comprises their most robust, mature rye aged from 9 to 11 years. At 109 proof, this exceptional variant offers a bold flavor profile with hints of vanilla, black pepper, honey, a mixture of fruits, a touch of spice, and rich oak undertones. See my in-depth review of Master's Keep Cornerstone Rye here.



WhistlePig Double Malt 18 Year Rye


Journey back to 2008, to a charismatic old farm in the quaint town of Shoreham, Vermont. Here, within these timeless walls, WhistlePig blossomed into a legend, claiming the esteemed title as the world’s premier rye whiskey artisan. The spirit of innovation infused with tradition, under the watchful eye of the late Master Distiller Dave Pickerell - a titan of craft whiskey - set the stage for what WhistlePig stands for today.


In the lush fields of the Green Mountain State, WhistlePig is on a mission to preserve the soul of rye whiskey while continually redefining its essence. It's where timeless craftsmanship meets audacity. Imagine a well-aged Double Malt Rye, cozied up in oak for 18 patient-years; this is the craft that WhistlePig has perfected with passion.


Step into our world of malted magic with our 4th Edition Double Malt—an alchemy of 79% rye, a generous 15% malted rye, and a touch of 6% malted barley. It's a symphony of taste that dances on the palate, blending the fiery zing of rye with the earthy whispers of malt. A flourish of richness, a hint of sweetness—all brought together by the lulling caress of the Spanish Pedro Ximenez sherry casks.


At a sturdy 92 proof, the latest iteration isn't just another bottle—it's an experience; complex, refined, and endlessly captivating. Toast and savor the legend that is WhistlePig, where every sip is a tribute to the timeless craft of exquisite rye whiskey. See my in-depth review of WhistlePig 18-year rye here.


Add to Your Home Bar


In conclusion, this curated list of the best rye whiskies is a tribute to the discerning palates seeking warmth and depth in their spirits. Affordability meets quality with our selection, offering newcomers an inviting gateway to savor the rich complexities of rye whiskey. For those moments that call for a toast to the extraordinary, my top-shelf options are more than mere drinks; they're experiences, wrapped in bottles that make exquisite gifts for loved ones or a luxurious treat to oneself. Elevate your home bar with these exceptional ryes and join the ranks of connoisseurs who appreciate the finer sips in life.


Check out my article on the best bourbon under $50.

Check out my article on the Best Wheated Bourbons.


Use my exclusive Caskers.com discount code: WHISKEYFOOL10 to receive $10 off qualifying* orders. Copy and paste to use at checkout.

*$100 or more
banner

Tags: best rye whiskey, the best rye whiskey, rye whiskey, straight rye, Kentucky straight rye, bottled in bond, oak barrels, flavor profile, best rye, smooth rye whiskey, jack daniel, dried fruit, stone fruit, 10 years, heaven hill, Pikesville rye, classic cocktails, green apple, charred oak, best rye whiskeys, Rittenhouse rye, straight rye whiskeys, baking spice, unique rye whiskey, charred oak barrels, spicy flavors, cask strength rye, Indiana rye, rich history, heaven hill, high rye, four years, traditional rye, rye aficionados

Other Reviews

bottom of page